Share this comment
Why would you assume that AGI is even a useful goal?
AGI is pretty much either A) a religious hallucination or B) kind of worthless.
We already have general intelligences - they're called humans. Improving those via genetic engineering holds far more promise than machine learning does for generating a better intelligence.
The goal of automa…
© 2025 Gary Marcus
Substack is the home for great culture
Why would you assume that AGI is even a useful goal?
AGI is pretty much either A) a religious hallucination or B) kind of worthless.
We already have general intelligences - they're called humans. Improving those via genetic engineering holds far more promise than machine learning does for generating a better intelligence.
The goal of automated systems is not to create intelligence but efficiency. You don't want your art AI to be smart, you want it to do what it is told.
AGI is pretty worthless in this regard (who wants a robot slave?), but generative AI is way more useful. You don't want intelligent robots, you want dumb ones that operate safely and efficiently.