16 Comments
User's avatar
Amy A's avatar

Harder to claim that you must be given access to everyone else’s copyrighted materials gratis when you can no longer claim to be a nonprofit defending humanity from your creation.

Expand full comment
Harry Bernstein's avatar

Would be nice if the AG forces some transparency.

Expand full comment
Gary Marcus's avatar

i shoulda said that at the end!

Expand full comment
Harry Bernstein's avatar

Coming from a legal background and fairly tech savvy, I had not heard the term "e/acc". After having Wikipedia bring me up to speed, I realized that I've read quite a bit put out by its advocates, primarily Andrew Ng. What concerns me is that they, like so many, see everything in black and white, this or that. I just don't get the lack of discourse. What's truly sad, is that honest discourse, listening, give and take is how we evolve.

Expand full comment
Chaos Goblin's avatar

I'll get the popcorn ready, it's always fun to watch e/accholes squirm.

Expand full comment
Gary Marcus's avatar

rotfl

Expand full comment
Chaos Goblin's avatar

"Knows"??

Giving ChatGPT pronouns?

And choosing "his", I have to notice?

The lion, the witch, the audacity of this bitch...

Expand full comment
huyen's avatar

they are considering turning it into for-profit corporation https://www.businessinsider.com/sam-altman-mulls-turning-openai-into-a-regular-company-2024-5.

Expand full comment
mjq66's avatar

Could they separate the non-profit from the for-profit? So that the non-profit keeps the "OpenAI" name and has the option to keep doing research, while the for-profit has to adopt a new name?

Expand full comment
Gary Marcus's avatar

see Public Citizen’s request to CA attorney general to do just that (discussed in an earlier post)

Expand full comment
Phil Tanny's avatar

The status quo will fight tooth and nail to maintain it's position, but in the end the most efficient means of production typically wins. As example, if OpenAI were completely dismantled, two weeks later we'd all be using a Chinese version of ChatGPT. Once a technology cat is let out of the bag, it runs wild in any direction it wants.

Expand full comment
Perry C. Douglas's avatar

“Non-profit” this is such a scam...even after all the game to thrones nonsense that happened with OpenAI/Microsoft. To still try to pass this off as non-profit is an insult to any even half thinking person. What a fraud.

Expand full comment
Hermogenes Rojas's avatar

Please, stop.

Your desire to see OpenAI and all research & development of LLM's and future AGI is a sad sight to behold.... be good Gary and try your best to contribute useful technical and scientific information to the field of Simulated Intelligence i.e. Artificial Knowledge Tools.

Expand full comment
Gary Marcus's avatar

That was a straight news article

If you wish to be uninformed feel free to unsubscribe

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 11, 2024Edited
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Jacob Kelter's avatar

I think the non profit owns a significant portion of the for-profit. So it's assets are worth a lot

Expand full comment